Title: Reconsidering Artificial Intelligence: A Future of Augmentation, Shared Prosperity, and Economic Empowerment
What if our perception of artificial intelligence (AI) has been inaccurate? Traditionally, AI is portrayed as a force that mimics human intelligence and replaces human labor. However, there is another possibility – AI could serve as a tool to enhance human productivity, without eliminating jobs. This alternate future could bring about increased prosperity and economic empowerment. But according to MIT economist Daron Acemoglu, society seems to be moving in a different direction – one where AI replaces jobs, intensifies surveillance, and exacerbates economic inequality. In this article, we’ll explore Acemoglu’s insights and the potential for AI to create a more inclusive and equitable society.
The Significance of AI and Power Distribution:
Acemoglu believes that major technological advancements, including AI, are closely intertwined with matters of power and control. While technology allows societies to increase productivity, the question remains as to how these benefits are shared. Consequently, AI’s development becomes crucial because it can either lead to broad-based benefits or further enrich a select few. The focus should shift from making machines intelligent on their own to making them increasingly useful for humans, augmenting human capability rather than replacing it.
The Productivity Bandwagon:
Acemoglu’s ideas align with those presented in his book, “Power and Progress: Our 1000-Year Struggle Over Technology and Prosperity” (co-written with Simon Johnson). The book highlights historical examples where the benefits of technology weren’t automatically shared widely. For instance, during the Industrial Revolution, it took a century before productivity gains were distributed among workers. Initially, real earnings stagnated, working hours increased, and labor conditions worsened. The same pattern emerged with Eli Whitney’s invention of the cotton gin, which exacerbated slavery in the United States. This highlights the need to proactively shape AI’s implementation so that benefits are shared more equitably.
Promoting Shared Prosperity:
Acemoglu emphasizes the importance of achieving what he and Johnson call “The Productivity Bandwagon.” This concept entails using technological innovation to assist workers rather than replacing them, leading to a more inclusive and prosperous society. Achieving this condition necessitates a significant amount of worker power, which has been diminishing over time. However, there is a tradition among technologists to prioritize making machines more useful for humans, and AI can follow this path as well.
Potential Challenges and Global Impact:
Commenting on Acemoglu’s talk, Fotini Christia noted the prevalence of these themes throughout history, citing Greek myths involving Daedalus, Icarus, and Prometheus. She raised important questions about AI’s impact, including concerns about greater problems compared to previous technological advancements and the role of different societal actors in driving change. Acemoglu acknowledged the need for greater worker power, encouraging workers to suggest productive uses for AI and actively advocate for policy changes.
Furthermore, Acemoglu warned of potential challenges for developing countries. China, for example, has been exporting AI surveillance technologies to various governments in the Global South. Additionally, countries that rely on low-wage industries to drive economic progress may face the risk of labor force displacement due to AI advancements. The accumulation of vast amounts of information by private companies and central governments worldwide could also lead to negative consequences, such as heightened inequality and reduced democratic rights.
In conclusion, Acemoglu’s insights prompt us to reconsider our perspective on AI. Rather than viewing it as a job replacement technology, AI should be harnessed to augment human capabilities and promote shared prosperity. The implementation of AI must involve conscious choices to ensure that its benefits are broadly distributed. Workers and policymakers alike must actively shape the path of AI to create an inclusive and equitable society. By doing so, we may unlock the potential of AI to transform the world for the better.